May 7, 2008

Psychiatrist Sued for Sex Abuse of Patient: Calgary

The Alberta College of Physicians and Surgeons has released a decision that it has revoked the medical licence of psychiatrist Jeremy Roberts.

Roberts was accused of "professional negligence and sexual abuse." A hearing found he had an inappropriate relationship with a patient that included sexual activity. The woman was not identified. The Alberta College's policy regarding doctor/patient sexual contact can be found here.

The Calgary Herald has reported that the patient that filed the complaint has filed a lawsuit against Roberts seeking compensation for sexual abuse.

The Herald reports that the plaintiff's Statement of Claim alleges that the woman went to see Roberts for treatment of anxiety, marital stress and postpartum depression. The woman had two young children and was still married when she first visited Roberts in January 2003.

Secret Marriage:

Ten months later, the woman alleges in the statement of claim, she and Roberts had sex in his office. They married in July 2005. It was only when the woman was hospitalized for harming herself, the statement of claim says, that she revealed the secret relationship.

Although Roberts has been disciplined by the College of Physicians, the facts alleged in the statement of claim have not been proven in court.

Doctor-Patient Sexual Abuse is a Persistent Problem:

This story points to a continuing problem. In a previous post I noted that the Ontario College of Physicians and Surgeons "regularly" deals with allegations of sexual abuse by doctors.

In 2002 the Ontario College of Physicians and Surgeons disciplined Dr. Russell Harold Frith and in 2004 they disciplined Dr. Charles Larry Leatherdale.

The Canadian Medical Association Journal has reported that in a survey of 792 Obstetricians and Gynaecologists across Canada 10% of the respondents indicated that they knew about another ob-gyn who at some time had been sexually involved with a patient!

For more information about civil claims for sexual abuse click here.

July 27, 2007

When is it okay for a doctor to have sex with their patients?

The Ontario College of Physicians and Surgeons is trying to "cure" the "chronic problem" of doctors sexually abusing their patients.

This story in the London Free Press reports that the College is:

"…floating an updated set of guidelines for physicians that contains advice on when it's appropriate for a doctor to be sexually intimate with someone they medically cared for in the past or a member of their patient's family."

When is it appropriate for doctors to have sex with their patients? Let me see…how about NEVER!

The doctor-patient relationship has to be one of the most powerful of fiduciary relationships. Patients have to place their complete trust in their physicians. Can there be a more vulernable position to be in?

The article reports that:

"…allegations of sexual abuse by doctors are heard regularly by the college's disciplinary committee."

For example:

A Toronto doctor for fondling and kissing his patient's breasts and sending her an essay containing sexual innuendo.

A Whitby doctor for having sexual relations with a patient and attempting to placate her husband by offering to prescribe him medication.

The statement "First do no harm" is widely attributed to Hippocrates, author of the Hippocratic oath. Perhaps these sexually abusive physicians have never of him?